By Greg Scott
The Unlikely Revolutionary: The Life and Legacy of Amor De Cosmos
In the annals of Canadian history, few figures stand out quite like Amor De Cosmos—a man whose very name seemed to encapsulate the audacity and eccentricity that marked his life. Born William Alexander Smith, he would become one of British Columbia’s most passionate and controversial leaders, a man driven by an unyielding vision for his adopted homeland. As premier of British Columbia, De Cosmos played a pivotal role in steering the colony toward Confederation with Canada, leaving a legacy that, like the man himself, was as complex as it was transformative.
Origins and Transformation: From William Smith to Amor De Cosmos
William Alexander Smith was born on August 20, 1825, in Windsor, Nova Scotia, a world away from the rugged Pacific coast where he would eventually make his mark. His early life was unremarkable, rooted in the rural landscapes of Nova Scotia, but there was something restless in young Smith, a yearning for a broader stage. In 1840, at the age of 15, he left Nova Scotia for the United States, seeking his fortune in the heady atmosphere of antebellum America.
It was during this time that Smith underwent a transformation—one that would define his identity and his destiny. In 1854, he adopted the name “Amor De Cosmos,” a Latin phrase meaning “Lover of the Universe.” The name change was more than a mere affectation; it was a declaration of intent, a symbol of his break with the past and his embrace of a new, larger-than-life persona. De Cosmos was a man who saw himself not just as an individual, but as a force of nature, a champion of progress and enlightenment. His chosen name reflected his belief in the boundless possibilities of the world and his place within it.
The Journey to British Columbia
In 1858, the same year that gold was discovered on the Fraser River, De Cosmos arrived in British Columbia, drawn by the promise of opportunity in the new colony. He was not a prospector or a trader, but a man of ideas, eager to shape the future of this nascent society. Upon his arrival, De Cosmos quickly immersed himself in the life of the colony, founding the British Colonist newspaper in Victoria. Through the Colonist, he became a vocal advocate for responsible government, free speech, and the development of British Columbia’s institutions.
De Cosmos’s writings in the Colonist were passionate and often polemical, reflecting his deep commitment to the principles of democracy and progress. He railed against what he saw as the entrenched power of the Hudson’s Bay Company and the colonial elite, calling for greater self-government and the development of public infrastructure. His editorials, written in a fiery and sometimes combative style, won him a following among the colony’s growing population of settlers, many of whom shared his vision for a more democratic and prosperous British Columbia.
The Road to Confederation: De Cosmos and the Union of the Colonies
By the 1860s, De Cosmos had become one of the leading voices in the movement for the unification of British Columbia’s two colonies—Vancouver Island and the mainland—under a single government. He argued that such a union was essential for the economic and political stability of the region, and he worked tirelessly to build support for the idea. His efforts bore fruit in 1866, when the two colonies were officially merged into the single Colony of British Columbia.
But for De Cosmos, the union of the colonies was only the first step in a larger plan. He believed that British Columbia’s future lay not as an isolated outpost on the edge of the Pacific, but as an integral part of the new Canadian Confederation. Canada, which had been formed in 1867 through the union of the British North American provinces, offered the promise of economic support, political stability, and national unity—benefits that De Cosmos was eager to secure for British Columbia.
De Cosmos became one of the most ardent advocates for British Columbia’s entry into Confederation. He argued that joining Canada would bring vital infrastructure, such as the construction of a transcontinental railway, which would link the isolated colony to the rest of the country. His vision was of a British Columbia that was not merely a remote appendage of the British Empire, but a thriving, connected province within a larger Canadian nation.
The Rise to Power: Premier of British Columbia
In 1871, British Columbia officially joined Confederation, and De Cosmos’s vision was realized. That same year, he was elected to the provincial legislature, where his reputation as a champion of Confederation propelled him to the forefront of British Columbia’s fledgling political landscape. In 1872, he became the second Premier of British Columbia, a position from which he sought to implement his ambitious agenda.
As premier, De Cosmos focused on the development of infrastructure, particularly the construction of roads, bridges, and other public works that would help integrate the province’s scattered communities. He was a tireless advocate for the completion of the Canadian Pacific Railway, which he saw as essential for the economic growth and unity of British Columbia. His government also pushed for education reforms, recognizing the need for a more educated populace to participate in the democratic process.
However, De Cosmos’s time as premier was not without its challenges. His fiery temperament and uncompromising nature, which had served him well as an advocate and editor, often made it difficult for him to navigate the complexities of political leadership. He clashed with opponents and even some allies, and his leadership style, characterized by a mix of visionary zeal and personal eccentricity, often led to controversy.
Politics and Personal Struggles
De Cosmos’s politics were driven by a deep belief in progress and the power of government to shape society for the better. He was a staunch advocate for responsible government, public education, and infrastructure development—issues that he believed were key to the future of British Columbia. However, his politics were also marked by contradictions. While he championed democracy and equality, his attitudes toward Indigenous peoples and non-European immigrants reflected the prejudices of his time. He supported policies that marginalized Indigenous communities and favored European settlement, seeing the latter as the key to the province’s development.
As his political career advanced, De Cosmos’s personal struggles became more pronounced. He was known for his eccentric behavior, including bouts of paranoia and reclusiveness, which some historians have speculated may have been symptoms of an undiagnosed mental illness. These personal challenges, combined with the political pressures of his office, eventually led to his resignation as premier in 1874.
After leaving office, De Cosmos continued to be involved in public life, serving as a Member of Parliament for Victoria. However, his influence waned, and he gradually retreated from the political scene. He spent his later years in relative obscurity, his once-fiery voice largely silent.
Legacy: A Visionary’s Mark on British Columbia
Amor De Cosmos died on July 4, 1897, in Victoria, leaving behind a legacy that is as complex as the man himself. He was a visionary who played a critical role in shaping the early political landscape of British Columbia, guiding the province into Confederation and laying the groundwork for its future development. His passionate advocacy for responsible government, public infrastructure, and education helped to establish the foundations of modern British Columbia.
Yet, De Cosmos’s legacy is also one of contradictions. He was a champion of democracy, yet his views on race and Indigenous peoples reflected the colonial attitudes of his time. He was a man of great ambition and intellect, yet his personal struggles often undermined his political career. In many ways, De Cosmos embodied the tensions of a rapidly changing world—a world in which old traditions were being challenged by new ideas, and where the future was being forged in the crucible of conflict and compromise.
Today, Amor De Cosmos is remembered as one of British Columbia’s founding figures, a man whose vision and determination helped to shape the province’s place within Canada. His life, marked by both triumph and tragedy, is a reminder of the complexities of leadership and the enduring impact of those who dare to dream beyond the boundaries of their time.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
